Energy V
This is the FIFTH of FIVE efforts to profile global energy issues
as they relate to similar challenges with water, climate, and food.
back to top.
Prelim
Letters From the Road
Wynton Marsalis, Artistic Director, Jazz at Lincoln Center, New York, NY
Web Link - Jazz at Lincoln Center
Clippings from the book To a Young Jazz Musician - Letters From the Road
by Wynton Marsalis, Random House, 2004
"June 18, 2003
"Dear Anthony,
"I've got a lot on my mind that needs passing to you. Today I'd like to cover a good bit of ground:...
some thoughts about the three P words - patience, persistence, and productivity.
"So let's rap about these P words a bit, patience first of all. Patience will enter in through many
doors: You need patience with the arc of your own development, and you need patience with your fellow
musicians, many of whom will be less than serious.
"And persistence? You need persistence because playing jazz is a life replete with self-doubt and difficulties
that never go away - they just change. Once you get on this road, you gonna be on it. It won't get easier.
...Gravity never stops pushing. Persistence helps you push back.
"And you have to be productive: What you do is what you will do..."
The notion of sustainability challenges the self to rethink. It is definitely somewhat like learning
music. It contains a lot of history, it has structure and rules but allows endless variations.
Marsalis' chosen words to illustrate the process are good ones - patience -
persistence - productivity . Three
sound guides for moving ahead with a complex subject.
Wynton Marsalis has won many awards world wide for both classical and jazz performance, arrangement and composition.
His masters classes are famous. The web links provide a bibliography and downloadable music tracks.
Web Link - Marsalis biography
Web Link - Marsalis discography
back to top.
Global Energy
Climate
Climate, of all the energy sources considered here over the past five weeks, seems the
most familiar but also the most convoluted. We wake up to it every day - the "weather" - and it is
a favorite topic of conversation. But this old familiar friend is suffering a pernicious
illness.
What we see and feel each day is nature's energy system at work - the transfer of solar
and gravitational effects into winds, tides, rain and ultimately into food. Left alone, it runs
just fine by itself. But, of course, it has not been "left alone" and there are issues with
climate that have unwittingly grown from
industrialization. Burning fossil fuels for power, industrial processes, and transportation have now skewed the
balance of nature and threaten our food stability and health.
At the launch of the 21st Century we have the following situation:
The world is growing by 70,000,000 people per year. This growth requires increases in
food production and increases in the transportation of people and goods. Both, food production
and transportation consume vast quantities of gasoline and both demand increasing amounts
of fresh water for life support and for irrigation of food crops. At this point in time,
the systems for growing
and distributing food and for manufacturing and delivering goods are based almost totally upon
energy produced by hydrocarbons (oil, gasoline, coal and natural gas). Burning these fuels releases
billions of new tons of carbon dioxide each year into the atmosphere. This carbon dioxide
has two properties: 1) it makes the atmosphere increasingly transparent to solar radiation
and 2) it traps heat reflected back from the earth's surface and thus progressively increases the
temperature at the surface of the globe.
The increases in temperature change weather patterns, reduce food harvests and produce
droughts which then escalate stresses
upon the basic life needs of an expanding population.
This condition known as "global warming" was first observed by Japanese scientists in the
1970's. At that time it was viewed somewhat as a curiosity. But now it is well
known that the
concentrations of CO2 have risen every year since precise measurements began in 1959,
making this one of the world's most predictable environmental trends. CO2 concentration turned
sharply upward in 1960 and roughly a decade later, around 1970,
the temperature began to climb and continues to do so.
Variations of the Earth's surface temperature 1000-2100. The temperature over the period
1000-1900 has been reconstructed from historical data. 20th century values are recorded data
and 21st century values are those predicted by the IPPCC scenarios. (Climate Change 2001:
Synthesis Report. Summary for Policymakers. IPCC 2001.)
Web Link - Chap. 4. The Green-House Effect, from Air and The Environment
Web Link - about IPCC
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has been established by
WMO and UNEP to assess scientific, technical and socio- economic information relevant for the understanding
of climate change, its potential impacts and options for
adaptation and mitigation. It is open to all Members of the UN and of WMO.
Recognizing the problem of potential global climate change, the World Meteorological Organization (WMO) and
the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) established the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
(IPCC) in 1988. It is open to all members of the
UN and WMO.
The role of the IPCC is to assess on a comprehensive, objective, open and transparent basis the scientific,
technical and socio-economic information relevant to understanding the scientific basis of risk of human-induced
climate change, its potential impacts and options for adaptation and mitigation. The IPCC does not carry out
research nor does it monitor climate related data or other relevant parameters. It bases its assessment mainly
on peer reviewed and published scientific/technical literature. Its role, organisation, participation and general
procedures are laid down in the "Principles Governing IPCC Work"
Related information:
Food Security
In recent years, numerous heat waves have lowered grain harvests in key food-producing
countries. In 2002 record-high temperatures and associated drought reduced grain harvests
in India, the United Sates and Canada, dropping the world harvest 89 million tons below consumption.
A rule of thumb emerging among crop ecologists is: a 1 degree Celsius rise in temperature
lowers wheat. rice, and corn yields by 10 percent.
Temperature is projected to rise as much as 5 degrees Celsius in this century. This increase will
be greater over land than over water. One of the higher projections is for the interior of
North America.
Increasing temperature has a dramatic effect on fresh water supply and on the amount
water available for crop irrigation. It is predicted that rising temperatures will continue to shrink
harvests and will eventually drive up food prices.
Energy
The cause of increased carbon dioxide concentration and the resulting temperature rise comes from two
primary sources: automobile emissions and coal burning power
plants. The challenge now is how to
rapidly implement alternatives.
For electric power generation there are many proven but less widely used options including wind power,
tidal power, hydro electricity, solar energy, geothermal energy and nuclear energy. All of these are in use.
As we know, there is strong and growing interest in rapidly expanding (in 3 to 10 year time frames) the use of
wind power, solar power, tidal power and nuclear power.
For transportation there are fewer proven options. Hybrid systems for vehicles and mass transit are the only
proven alternates at this time. However, the use of these alternatives could produce huge changes. If the United
States "fleet" of automobiles were to be converted over ten years to hybrid system
vehicles - such as the Toyota Prius, the Honda Civic and others coming to market soon, U.S. gasoline consumption
would be cut by 50% - and likewise, harmful emissions cut by 50%.
Climate change due to CO2 emissions is a fact. How and when its negative effects may be corrected is not known.
The quote cited below from the National Academy of Sciences says in part "...the earth's climate system
behaves more like a "switch" than a "dial".
That is, climate appears to jump abruptly from one relatively stable state to another relatively stable state,
much as a light switch responds only after being pushed for some distance, and then it goes all at once..."
This represents a frightening prospect but perhaps also represents an opportunity to reverse the situation through quick,
encompassing and remedial actions.
Sources and Resources
World Watch Institute - Research Library
Web Link - Energy:Climate Change
Earth Policy Institute
Web Link - Outgrowing the Earth
National Academy of Sciences
Web Link - Discovery Engine - Reports on Climate
Frontiers of Science: Global Climate Change
Abrupt Climate Change Inferred from Thermally-fractionated Gases in Polar Ice
Jeff Severinghaus
Scripps Institution of Oceanography
Recent discoveries from the Greenland ice core drilling program and from sediment cores in much of the
world have demonstrated that the earth's climate warmed abruptly, in less than a decade and perhaps as
little as three years, during and at the end of the lastice age some 11,000 years ago. The new view that
is emerging from these studies is that the earth's climate system behaves more like a "switch" than a "dial".
That is, climate appears to jump abruptly from one relatively stable state to another relatively stable state,
much as a light switch responds only after being pushed for some distance, and then it goes all at once. This
fast speed of change stands in marked contrast to the gradual warming that is generally discussed in the
context of greenhouse warming over the next 50 to 100 years. If for some reason such an abrupt event were
to happen now, it would be far more destructive to society than the greenhouse-gas induced warming that is
generally expected, because society's adaptation to a change is critically affected by the speed of the change.
Some modeling studies suggest that greenhouse gas emissions may in fact trigger such a surprise. While the
possible effect of greenhouse gas emissions remains speculative, there is no doubt that these abrupt events
did occur in the past, and are a regular and characteristic feature of the climate system. In that sense,
they are certain to occur again, though we cannot predict when.
U.S. Department of Agriculture
Web Link - NRCS - National Water and Climate Center
World Bank
Web Link - A Review of Country Case Studies on Climate Change